Home title theft: What you should know

House title theft is a serious crime that can strip homeowners of their property without warning. Victims of identity theft are more vulnerable to this kind of fraud, which occurs when criminals transfer property ownership without the owner’s consent. Criminals may exploit weaknesses in property records to illegally transfer property deeds, leaving homeowners to fight for their most valuable asset. Understanding house title theft and how to protect yourself can help prevent it before it happens. In this article we’ll break down the steps you can take so house title theft won’t happen to you.

What is home title theft?

Home title theft is rare, but when it happens, it can be one of the most unsettling forms of identity and property fraud a homeowner can face. In this crime, a fraudster poses as you, often using forged deeds, falsified documents, or stolen personal information. Once they’ve established a false claim to ownership, they can sell the home, transfer the title, or take out loans against its equity, leaving you to fight to prove the property is rightfully yours.

If successful, a title thief can create serious legal entanglements that jeopardize your finances, credit, and even your right to stay in your home. It can take months — or even years — to untangle the mess, and often requires legal assistance, court intervention, and proof that you’re the rightful owner.

No two cases look the same, but title theft generally falls into one of these categories:

• Mortgage fraud: A thief uses your property as collateral for a cash-out refinance or home equity loan, takes the money, and leaves you responsible for repayment.
• Refinance fraud: A scammer uses your identity to take out a new loan against your home, pulling out its equity and leaving you with a mortgage you never agreed to. While they don’t take ownership of your property, they can still drain its value and damage your finances.
• Home equity line of credit (HELOC) fraud: A fraudster taps into your home’s equity through a HELOC, borrowing large sums in your name. You may be left fighting to clear your credit and restore your financial standing until you can prove the debt isn’t yours.
• Forged deeds: Scammers sometimes create or alter property documents to make it appear as though they legally own your home. This tactic is especially common with vacant properties, rentals, or vacation homes, where the actual owner might not notice anything wrong right away. ****
• Fraudulent sale: The scammer uses stolen or forged ownership documents to sell your home without your knowledge. In many cases, the buyer has no idea the sale is illegal until the actual owner steps in.
• Fraudulent transfer: Instead of selling your home, the scammer changes the title into their own or another person’s name without your consent. This false transfer can set the stage for taking out loans against the property or selling it later.

Victims of identity theft are particularly vulnerable to house title theft, since criminals who already have your details can more easily create falsified documentation. And with technology like artificial intelligence making forgeries more convincing, understanding the risks more important than ever — even if the odds are low.

The good news is that by staying informed, monitoring your property records, and investing in home title protection, such as an owner’s title insurance policy, you can dramatically reduce your exposure to this type of crime and keep both your home and your peace of mind secure.

How common is home title theft?

Thankfully, house title theft is relatively rare compared to other types of fraud. In 2024, the FBI received 9,359 complaints in the broader real estate crime category, totaling nearly $175 million in losses. https://wtop.com/real-estate/2025/08/home-title-theft-how-to-prevent-it/?utm_source=chatgpt.com There are no exact numbers for title theft specifically, but the FBI’s 2023 report listed 9,521 real estate-related internet crimes with $145 million in losses, which includes all property fraud, not just title theft.

Meanwhile, from 2019 – 2023, the FBI recorded 58,141 victims of real estate fraud nationwide with losses totaling $1.3 billion. Investing in home title protection, such as an owner’s title insurance policy, can provide a valuable safeguard against potential fraud.

Scammers are constantly adapting their tactics. In some recent cases, thieves have used AI-generated documents and deepfake signatures to bypass identity checks, making it even harder for victims to spot the fraud early. That’s why it’s so important to layer your defenses with regular record monitoring and home title protection tools like title insurance.

Signs of home title theft

Being observant is one of your best defenses. Here are red flags you shouldn’t ignore:

• Unexpected home loans on your credit report. New accounts, like a second mortgage, HELOC, or refinance you didn’t authorize, could indicate that someone is using your property as collateral.
• Unsolicited buyer interest. If you receive calls, emails, or texts from iBuyer firms or other buyers asking about a home you never listed, it could mean your property is being marketed without your knowledge. Ask how they found the listing and where it appeared.
• Missing mortgage communications. If your regular statements, escrow notices, or tax documents stop arriving, it could be because someone changed the mailing address on your account to hide suspicious activity.

Catching these signs of home title theft early gives you a much better chance of stopping fraud before it causes severe damage.

How to prevent house title theft

Here’s how to stay one step ahead:

1. Keep track of all homeowner mail: Regularly reviewing your routine bills, mortgage statements, tax notices, and insurance documents helps you spot missing or duplicate mail quickly, both of which can indicate tampering.

2. Check your credit report routinely: Sign up for alerts for new loans or HELOCs. Credit monitoring services let you know when a new account is opened so you can stay a step ahead of addressing potential fraud.

3. Get title insurance: An owner’s title insurance policy can help protect you if someone tries to fraudulently claim ownership of your home. It typically covers claims of forgery or identity theft.

4. Monitor your property records: Many counties offer free or affordable fraud alerts when changes are filed. Sign up to get notified whenever a document is recorded under your name or property address.

5. Stay informed about common scams: Fraud tactics evolve quickly, especially with AI making forged deeds harder to spot. Explore Rocket’s list of common mortgage scams so you know what to watch for and how to protect your home.

6. Strengthen your digital defenses: Many title theft cases start with stolen personal information. Use strong, unique passwords for your mortgage, banking, and insurance accounts, and enable two-factor authentication wherever possible. Avoid sharing sensitive documents over unsecured email. Opt for encrypted file-sharing when you need to send paperwork.

7. Store your property records securely: Hold on to paper copies of important documents like your deed, title policy, and closing paperwork by keeping them in a secure spot—like a bank’s safe deposit box or a fireproof safe at home. For digital versions, use a secure, backed-up location that isn’t easy for hackers to access.

Reporting home title theft

If you notice signs of trouble, take action right away to reclaim your title and protect your identity. Here’s where to start:

• Contact your lender immediately: Let them know there’s fraudulent activity tied to your title or mortgage accounts.
• Notify all three credit bureaus : Set up credit alerts and report any fraudulent new lines of credit.
• Report to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) : File an identity theft report at IdentityTheft.gov.
• File a police report: Provide dates and details, such as unauthorized loans, filings, or suspicious communications, to get on record. Bring your ID, proof of address, and any other relevant documents.
• Change mortgage account passwords and freeze your credit: A credit freeze will stop new accounts from being opened in your name and adds another layer of security. Learn more about credit freezes .

Each of these actions documents the crime and helps create a paper trail to support your legal case. A police report may be required by your title insurer or lender before they take corrective action. Contacting the credit bureaus ensures that fraudulent accounts are flagged quickly, minimizing further financial damage.

What to do if you’re a victim of home title theft

Even after you’ve reported the crime, there’s more you can do to reclaim your property and restore your records:

• Work with your title insurance company . If you have an owner’s title insurance policy, file a claim right away. The insurer can provide legal support to help you remove fraudulent liens or reverse an illegal transfer.
• Hire a real estate attorney . An experienced attorney can guide you through court processes, challenge fraudulent deeds, and represent you in disputes with lenders or buyers who were misled.
• Check county property records regularly . After resolving the immediate fraud, monitor your title for at least a year to ensure no new false documents are filed.
• Review your credit report monthly . Keep watch for lingering impacts, like hard inquiries or accounts tied to fraudulent activity.

How long it takes to clear your title really depends on how complicated the fraud is—it could be resolved in a few weeks or drag on for over a year. Staying on top of things by keeping all your paperwork, emails, and legal documents organized can make the process a lot less overwhelming.

The bottom line: Protect your home from real estate scams

Home title theft doesn’t happen often, but when it does, the consequences can be serious. Being proactive — keeping an eye on your property records, staying informed, and having protection like title insurance — can go a long way in keeping your home safe. The more you understand how these scams work, the better you can guard what’s yours.

Samantha is a full-time personal finance and real estate writer with 5 years of experience. She has a Bachelor of Science in Finance and an MBA from West Chester University of Pennsylvania. She writes for publications like Visto Mortgage, Bigger Pockets, Quicken Loans, Angi, Well Kept Wallet, Crediful, Clever Girl Finance, AllCards, InvestingAnswers, and many more.

If you’re behind on your mortgage and facing foreclosure, you still have ways to avoid losing your home. Learn how to confidently navigate this legal proc…

Reverse mortgages are complicated and difficult to understand, which is why you need to be alert to potential scams. Learn how to avoid reverse mortgage fraud.

A title company is a third party that works on behalf of both the lender and the buyer. Learn more about what title companies do in the home buying process.